404 21st Street, Mattoon, Illinois 61938

Subdivision > Not Applicable

$184,900

For Sale
Status: Contingent
Sqft: 1,876
Cost/Sqft: $99
Beds: 3
Baths: 2
Year Built: 1906
Property Taxes: $2,995
Days On Market: 25
Lot Size: 0,16
Map
Street View

Description

Beautifully updated and filled with character, this 3-bedroom, 2-bath home has so much to offer! As you enter, a gorgeous staircase immediately catches your eye, surrounded by beautifully detailed original trim that continues throughout the home. Tall ceilings, spacious rooms, and large windows bring in plenty of natural light and add to the open, welcoming feel. The kitchen has been beautifully refreshed with refinished cabinetry and stainless steel appliances, while modern updates throughout the home blend nicely with its original character. A sunroom provides additional living space and is a wonderful spot to relax and enjoy the natural light. The list of improvements is extensive! Since the seller purchased the home, numerous major improvements have been completed. 2025 updates include a new furnace, power-vent water heater, 3-stage whole-house water filtration system with PEX, gutters and gutter guards, new patio door, new basement stairs, new water line to the street, and new sump pump. The garage also has electrical service and a new smart garage door opener. Major exterior improvements were completed in 2024, including a new roof, siding, soffit, and fascia. The garage also received a new roof, siding, soffit, fascia, and overhead door. Additional improvements include 200-amp electrical service, updated electrical and plumbing, newer interior doors and windows, and all-new insulated ductwork. Outside, the large, fully fenced backyard offers plenty of room to relax, entertain, or enjoy time outdoors. With its gorgeous original details, beautiful updates, and so many major improvements already completed, this is a home that truly stands out the moment you walk through the door!

Property Specifics

Single Family
—
—
1906
—
—
No
0.16
Coles
Not Applicable
— / Not Applicable
—
—
—
12755894
07210014000000

Nearby Schools

NAME: DISTRICT: DISTANCE:
Grade School
Riddle Elementary School
2 —
Middle School
Mattoon Middle School
2 Not in DB
High School
Mattoon High School
2 Not in DB

Property History

DATE: EVENT: PRICE: SOURCE:
19 Sep, 2026 Under contract $184,900 MRED MLS
16 Sep, 2026 Listed for sale $184,900 MRED MLS

Room Specifics

All Bedroom Info:
Total Bedrooms: 3
Bedrooms Above Ground: 3
Bedrooms Below Ground: 0
Second Bedroom Info:
Dimensions: —
Location: —
Floor Type: —
Third Bedroom Info:
Dimensions: —
Location: —
Floor Type: —
Bathroom Info:
Full Bathrooms: 2
Partial Bathrooms: 0
Bathroom Amenities: —
Bathroom in Basement: 0
Additional Rooms Info:
Rooms: —
Basement: —
Basement Description: —

Other Specifics

2
—
—
—
—
50 X 143
—
—
—
—
Not in DB
—
—
—
—

Tax History

Year Property Taxes
2026 $2,995

Nearby Similar Homes

2105 Dewitt Avenue, Mattoon, Illinois 61938
For Sale
$69,900
2 beds / 1.0 baths / 1,033 ft2
Single Family / Built: 1900
27

2516 Pine Avenue, Mattoon, Illinois 61938
For Sale
$29,000
2 beds / 1.0 baths / 2,110 ft2
Single Family / Built: 1907
219

109 26th Street, Mattoon, Illinois 61938
For Sale
$35,000
2 beds / 1.0 baths / 936 ft2
Single Family / Built: 1917
50

Nearby Sold Comparables

2012 Moultrie Ave, Mattoon, Illinois 61938
Sold
$8,500
2 beds / 1.0 baths / 1,030 ft2
Single Family / Built: —
4442

5290 Rt 173 Highway, Richmond, Illinois 60071
Sold
$349,900
2 beds / 2.0 baths / 4,268 ft2
Single Family / Built: 1990
3827

505 18th Street, Mattoon, Illinois 61938
Sold
$7,500
3 beds / 1.0 baths / 8,002 ft2
Single Family / Built: 1940
3779

2209 Dewitt Avenue, Mattoon, Illinois 61938
Sold
$64,000
1 beds / 1.0 baths / 800 ft2
Single Family / Built: 1956
426

2304 Moultrie Avenue, Mattoon, Illinois 61938
Sold
$77,500
2 beds / 1.0 baths / 1,192 ft2
Single Family / Built: 1950
1503

Mattoon, Illinois 61938
Sold
$69,900
2 beds / 2.0 baths / 2,230 ft2
Single Family / Built: 1900
4864


Contact Agent

Listing Provided By

KELLER WILLIAMS-TREC