5435 Newcastle Avenue, Garfield Ridge, Chicago, Illinois 60638


$390,000

Sold
Status: Closed
Sqft: 2,148
Cost/Sqft: $175
Beds: 3
Baths: 2
Year Built: 1946
Property Taxes: $4,380
Days On Market: 203
Lot Size: 0,00

Description

**Multiple Offers Received, Highest & Best due Monday 4/13 12pm** Impeccably maintained Cape Cod on an oversized lot in the heart of Garfield Ridge, just steps from Byrne Elementary, dining, and Normandy Park. This charming home features a functional main-level layout with beautifully preserved hardwood floors, a sun-drenched open-concept living and dining area, and a convenient first-floor bedroom and full bath. The second floor offers generous storage with oversized closets and custom built-ins, adding both character and practicality. A finished basement with exterior access provides versatile additional living space, ideal for entertaining, with a dedicated laundry area and ample storage. Major recent improvements include a new roof (2025), AC condenser (2026), furnace (2023), second-floor carpeting (2026), new garage windows (2026), and freshly painted throughout (2026). Both bathrooms have been recently remodeled with high-end finishes, including porcelain tile, a whirlpool tub, and Toto toilets. Enjoy a fully fenced and landscaped backyard, perfect for outdoor relaxation. A move-in ready Chicago charmer, ready for its next chapter.

Property Specifics

Single Family
—
—
1946
—
—
—
—
No
—
Cook
—
— / Not Applicable
—
—
—
—
—
12612605
19073300120000

Property History

DATE: EVENT: PRICE: SOURCE:
8 May, 2026 Sold $390,000 MRED MLS
13 Apr, 2026 Under contract $374,999 MRED MLS
8 Apr, 2026 Listed for sale $374,999 MRED MLS

Room Specifics

All Bedroom Info:
Total Bedrooms: 3
Bedrooms Above Ground: 3
Bedrooms Below Ground: 0
Bathroom Info:
Full Bathrooms: 2
Partial Bathrooms: 0
Bathroom Amenities: Whirlpool, Separate Shower
Bathroom in Basement: 0
Additional Rooms Info:
Rooms: —
Basement: —

Other Specifics

2
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
30X125
—
—
—
—
Not in DB
—
—
—

Tax History

Year Property Taxes
2026 $4,380

Nearby Similar Homes

5320 Oak Park Avenue, Chicago, Illinois 60638
For Sale
$424,700
3 beds / 2.0 baths / 1,355 ft2
Single Family / Built: 1947
27

5533 Sayre Avenue, Chicago, Illinois 60638
For Sale
$539,000
4 beds / 2.0 baths / 2,200 ft2
Single Family / Built: 1968
42

5704 Oak Park Avenue, Chicago, Illinois 60638
For Sale
$565,000
4 beds / 3.0 baths / 2,461 ft2
Single Family / Built: 1953
22

5708 Newcastle Avenue, Chicago, Illinois 60638
For Sale
$349,900
4 beds / 2.0 baths / 1,863 ft2
Single Family / Built: 1966
8

5721 Newcastle Avenue, Chicago, Illinois 60638
For Sale
$699,999
4 beds / 3.1 baths / 3,000 ft2
Single Family / Built: 1949
26

5655 Normandy Avenue, Chicago, Illinois 60638
For Sale
$290,000
2 beds / 1.0 baths / 886 ft2
Single Family / Built: 1946
83

Nearby Sold Comparables

Chicago, Illinois 60638
Sold
$264,900
3 beds / 2.0 baths / 0 ft2
Single Family / Built: 1951
6712

5427 Newcastle Avenue, Chicago, Illinois 60638
Sold
$479,000
3 beds / 2.0 baths / 1,200 ft2
Single Family / Built: 1963
357

5423 Newcastle Avenue, Chicago, Illinois 60638
Sold
$409,000
2 beds / 2.0 baths / 1,741 ft2
Single Family / Built: 1942
530

5429 Newcastle Avenue, Chicago, Illinois 60638
Sold
$279,900
4 beds / 2.0 baths / 1,776 ft2
Single Family / Built: 1948
2909

5447 Newcastle Avenue, Chicago, Illinois 60638
Sold
$220,000
4 beds / 2.0 baths / 0 ft2
Single Family / Built: 1955
4552

5440 Oak Park Avenue, Chicago, Illinois 60638
Sold
$395,800
3 beds / 2.0 baths / 2,112 ft2
Single Family / Built: 1956
1095


Contact Agent

Listing Provided By

Realty of America, LLC